written by Ava Spano and Chloe Pyhrr
During our six-week summer course in Florence, one dish we kept ordering again and again was cacio e pepe. It’s a simple dish made with just three ingredients, cheese, black pepper, and pasta. But somehow, it never gets old. We ended up trying it at three different spots, and each time it was a little different—but always so good. But why? Read more if you need further convincing…
What Is Cacio e Pepe?
Cacio e pepe translates to “cheese and pepper,” and that’s exactly what it is. It’s made with just pasta, Pecorino Romano, cracked black pepper, and pasta water to make it creamy.
The dish originally came from Ancient Rome. It was traditionally made by Shepards who would be away in the countryside for long stretches of time. They needed food that was simple, portable, and most importantly nonperishable. The dried pasta was lightweight and lasted forever. Pecorino Romano, a salty aged sheep’s cheese, wouldn’t spoil easily. And black pepper was used for flavor and its warming properties on chilly mountain nights. With those few ingredients, they could make a filling, satisfying meal wherever they were. Over time, what started as a shepherd’s survival food evolved into a symbol of Roman culinary identity. Today, cacio e pepe is considered one of the “holy trinity” of Roman pasta dishes, alongside carbonara and amatriciana.
What makes cacio e pepe so special is how it embodies everything Italian food is known for: simplicity, balance, and respect for ingredients. It’s a reminder that great cooking isn’t about how many things you put into a dish, but how well you understand the ones you do.
Throughout the summer, we tasted cacio e pepe in all kinds of places—from cozy, traditional spots to more modern and trendy restaurants. Each version reflected the personality of where we were and taught us something new—not just about the dish, but about the culture and story behind it.
Where We Tried It
We tried it at three different restaurants, and each one had its own take on the dish. On our first night in Florence, we tried Il Teatro. It was an authentic feeling restaurant, with its cacio e pepe priced at 12 euro. We had been recommended the place for its’ amazing cacio e pepe, so without even knowing what the dish actually was, we ordered it. The cacio e pepe had a great texture, the pepper came through without being overwhelming, and the cheese sauce was super flavorful. After that first bowl at Il Teatro, we were hooked; we decided we needed to continue trying new versions of the dish everywhere we went.
The next place we tried was unironically named Cacio & Pepe. The pasta definitely lived up to its name, the pici pasta were thick and fresh, and the sauce was perfectly creamy. It felt super rich but still really balanced. The pasta was priced at 17.50 euro, making it one of the more expensive dishes we’ve tried. Regardless, it was delicious and worth trying, with great service and a cozy ambiance.
The last place we tried was Trattoria Marone, it came highly recommended from friends who’ve studied abroad prior, coining it “the best food we’d eat in Italy.” It is known for its extensive menu and an extremely busy tourist spot. The pasta was reasonably priced, flavorful, peppery, and well made. It wasn’t too creamy, but the cheese and pepper flavor stood out in the best way. The best part of our experience was the ambiance; we sat in a cozy corner of the beautiful authentic restaurant and had the best view to people watch throughout the restaurant. It really drove home the beauty of Florence, with a simple yet delicious dish and good company. We will continue the tradition of recommending this place to our friends who study abroad in the future. It was an amazing experience, somewhere we’d definitely go back to again.
Final Thoughts
It’s kind of crazy how the same few ingredients can taste so different depending on where you go. Each place we tried brought something new to our experience, and we loved all three for different reasons. Whether it was the comforting and flavorful version at Il Teatro, the creamy sauce at Cacio e Pepe, or the bold, classic flavors at Trattoria Marone, they all made us appreciate the dish in a new way.
If you’re ever in Florence, definitely try cacio e pepe more than once. It’s such a simple meal, but it quickly became one of our favorites. And trust us, it is great every time.